If you need urgent support, call 999 or go to your nearest A&E. To contact our Crisis Messenger (open 24/7) text THEMIX to 85258.
Options
Take a look around and enjoy reading the discussions. If you'd like to join in, it's really easy to register and then you'll be able to post. If you'd like to learn what this place is all about, head here.
Comments
Now, of course, correlation doesn't equate to causation - and would it be more guns causing more deaths, or more deaths causing people to get more guns for protection
And of the countries that are below New Hampshire on your link, 3 are actually below it according to this list and 8 are not even on that list.
And Poland is right on the line with New Hampshire, but I'll give you that one anyway. So, assuming that all of the MIA countries are still lower than New Hampshire, that means New Hampshire beats fifteen countries and is only beaten by ten.
Your link's source material is quite old with the majority of the individual country's statistics, a decade or more older than the U.S. state ones. In fact, if you look at the dates, the countries with the higher rates tend to have their dates in the 2000s more often than the lower ones.
The NationMaster link's statistics' minimum date range is 1998 with the general pool being 2000, which while still old, shows the progression of time. For example, Germany's stats, which is 1994 in your link, has a higher gun homicide rate than New Hampshire in 2000 despite having a lower one in 1994.
And remember, as Jessi established earlier, gun violence in England/Wales rose after 1998, which was after the sourced material in your link (when followed.)
I stick by my guns (lol) in declaring statistics bullshit, but if one is to read these statistics, it's pretty obvious that the U.S.'s gun homicide rate is relatively average relative to its size.
Yeah, rookie mistake. I should have checked rather than going from memory *facepalm*
Only if you think that having the 14th highest rate in the world is average.
Which ever way you have tried to argue and cut these statistics, the US and a nation (and most states) still comes out higher than the vast majority of nations.
Hardly "average"
Okay.
Erm, which would mean that the USA should have lower gun crime than England, because its population density is much lower. That's using your logic, but somehow you're using it as an excuse for the USAs (apparent) high rate of gun crime.
You've tried to cut these statistics in every possible way to make it beneficial to your argument. Individual states, the whole of the EU rather than comparing to countries, then it doesn't count because of the date, or because America is bigger. And finally, when none of these are working for you, you simply state that statistics are bullshit. :rolleyes:
Look, I have no opinion on whether widespread gun ownership correlates with an increase in homicide generally, which is surely the main issue, but the idea that it doesn't correlate with an increase in homicide by firearms is ludicrous, and not borne out by any of the statistics (but I know, they must be bullshit if they don't support your argument).
I've already demonstrated everything I need to. So, the rest of your post is water off a duck's ass for me at this point.
And of course statistics are bullshit. That's your little get-out clause before you even start. Doesn't stop you being very keen for everyone to read some statistics when you think they happen to support your views though, does it?
Mark Twain famously said "There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies and statistics." Since then, there have been books written that support the premise. Check out "Damned Lies and Statistics: Untangling Numbers from the Media, Politicians, and Activists" by Joel Best.
For the sake of conducting intellectual argument, I will debate statistics, but they are hardly an end-all, be-all to debate. Never once did I say "The statistics support me, so obviously I'm right about guns." Not once.
Er... yeah.
Sums up your argument. You're still on my ignore list though.
[Homer] Hhmmm ignore list [/Homer]