If you need urgent support, call 999 or go to your nearest A&E. To contact our Crisis Messenger (open 24/7) text THEMIX to 85258.
Read the community guidelines before posting ✨
Autism or “Autistic”
Siena
Posts: 15,681 Skive's The Limit
Heya everyone. Hope everyone’s okay! 👌 just a healthy interesting debate carried on from support chat. Wanted to know more people’s opinion
Please remember your opinion isn’t right if not facts. We all have different opinions and should appreciate that. But it’s interesting to know why
Mental illness or not. I will not called someone autistic (unless they wanna be called it). Because it’s not their own identity. some people go like hi I’m *name* and I’m autistic like it their whole identity and belong to one community and that’s being autistic who act the same when it’s not . What about hi I’m *name* and I like dogs and I have autism. Or is liking dogs, apart of your autistim and there is nothing else about you apart from your autism Calling your self austiic - You put the stereotypes in your head of oh this is them. Without thinking about anything else they could possibly be. Say I have autistim means it’s just still who you are but it’s only apart of you. There are many things about you. Mental illness or not. There is still assumptions of what autistim looks like when everyone is not the same.
I would hate for someone to call me borderline. Like can you imagine. They would think of all the awful conitations to it like being manipulative and wouldn’t think about who I am. Not my diagnosis. I know this is a mental illness but it still has the same concept. Like I don’t want to be put in a group of people of “ borderlines”when I am my own person. Which I’m pretty sure I’d fee the same if I had autistim. I wouldn’t want to be put into a group of “autistic” like oh you’re autistic and that’s it about you, don’t need to know anything else. Like yeah it’s a common thing people in that group have but you’re still your own person and I personally think that’s why some like to be called it. So they fee apart of a community or “autistics”. Obviously I could be wrong but as someone who doesn’t have autism that’s how I view it.
My Options in the poll with have “ I have autism” sorry if that offends anyone.
Please remember your opinion isn’t right if not facts. We all have different opinions and should appreciate that. But it’s interesting to know why
Mental illness or not. I will not called someone autistic (unless they wanna be called it). Because it’s not their own identity. some people go like hi I’m *name* and I’m autistic like it their whole identity and belong to one community and that’s being autistic who act the same when it’s not . What about hi I’m *name* and I like dogs and I have autism. Or is liking dogs, apart of your autistim and there is nothing else about you apart from your autism Calling your self austiic - You put the stereotypes in your head of oh this is them. Without thinking about anything else they could possibly be. Say I have autistim means it’s just still who you are but it’s only apart of you. There are many things about you. Mental illness or not. There is still assumptions of what autistim looks like when everyone is not the same.
I would hate for someone to call me borderline. Like can you imagine. They would think of all the awful conitations to it like being manipulative and wouldn’t think about who I am. Not my diagnosis. I know this is a mental illness but it still has the same concept. Like I don’t want to be put in a group of people of “ borderlines”when I am my own person. Which I’m pretty sure I’d fee the same if I had autistim. I wouldn’t want to be put into a group of “autistic” like oh you’re autistic and that’s it about you, don’t need to know anything else. Like yeah it’s a common thing people in that group have but you’re still your own person and I personally think that’s why some like to be called it. So they fee apart of a community or “autistics”. Obviously I could be wrong but as someone who doesn’t have autism that’s how I view it.
My Options in the poll with have “ I have autism” sorry if that offends anyone.
“And when they look at you, they won't see everything you've been through. They won't see the **** that turned to scars that began to fade with time. They won't see the heartbreaking things that shook up and changed your entire world. They won't know how many tears you cried or even what it was you were crying about. They won't see how strong you had to be because you had no other choice. What they will see though is how compassionate you are because you experienced pain. What they will see is how kind you are because you experienced how cruel the world is. What they will see is how good you are because you've seen how bad things or people can be. The difference between you and your experiences are who you choose to be, despite everything that could have turned you cold and unkind.You are the good the world needs and the best of us.” ~ Kirsten Corley
Autism or “Autistic” 9 votes
0
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Also as a thought for next time maybe make the poll private
But I won't speak too much as it is up to those who have it in particular or those with a bit more experience of it at least to think what would work. I think its a difficult topic, but I think its a bit different as a condition to some of the other things out there.
As a counterpoint I think certain things like sexuality or being deaf etc. you almost always refer to yourself as being such rather than having such and would be strange to hear otherwise maybe some part that is convention, but with sexuality like homosexuality for example people for a long time tried to state how it is a innate fixed thing and not a illness.
Though there is the idea of fluidity too in sexuality and ofc it shouldn't define you and it doesn't mean you are part a community necesarily unless u want to be.
Interestingly though, I remember having a conversation with one of my best friends about this. He was saying he much prefers referring to himself as 'autistic' because he sees it as such a big part of who he is. I think he said 'it's literally woven through every part of me' or something. It really made me reconsider the person first language and realise it's not actually that clear cut.
So I wonder if it can depend on what thing we're talking about. There might be an argument to be made for using person first language when talking about anxiety, depression, or other things that you can recover from. But I wonder if it's a bit different for things are neurological (like autism or ADHD) that are always going to be there, and might feel like a bigger part of you.
There might not be a right answer here, and as @Millie2787 said it's best to use whatever the person prefers if you're not sure how to refer to an individual. It's obvious that person first language is well-intentioned and some people might not mind either way, but interesting nonetheless.
Thanks for sharing
but until said otherwise I would carry on. Like if someone said don’t say that to me I wouldn’t. But otherwise I would speak in a way that I think is the less offensive… not assuming anything just say what I would think would want to be called
I agree would feel weird
Yeah that’s quite interesting about how one of your friends said it.
Thanks for sharing. I think either way I would said someone with autism as you can’t go wrong. And I don’t think someone could be offended by that as like you said obviously well intended. But I can see how someone could be offended by being label as autistic. And I don’t want to assume that just because a few people have said it here that everyone wants to be referred that way. So for me that would be the safest option
you make it sound like I’m gunna go up to someone and be like you’re not autistic you have autism lol. I mean, specifically referring to on my one person to their face is rarely ever going to happen in my life. Like I’m not gunna go like oh hi Fred with autism. I’m speaking like generally like something like “oh I don’t have many friends who have autism” “rather than I don’t have autistic friends”. Like most of the time you only ever use it when being general. And if the person I’m speaking to get offended by that then i don’t know id apologise and think it was a bit weird as one person don’t represent the whole community to feel like even if I’m not speaking about them that Theyd be offended. Would think it’s weird but carry on with my day lol
I think its due to the fact that autism isn't a condition/illness, its just about how the brian is wired, so it's not a negative thing, even if it can cause hindrance.
@Shaunie I do kind of agree that "with autism" is the safer option, but I think that's honestly just due to the stigma around autism. Someone referring to themselves as "autistic" probably only sounds harsh because we don't hear it often, and autism is seen as a disability by a lot of people.
Every autistic person I know that has spoken about this prefers "autistic" than "with autism" but yeah it has more risk of sounding rude to others
It is a well known assumption when parents are like oh that’s kids playing up. And the parents are like he has autism then people think it’s an excuse but obviously not. So i don’t know how never heard of that assumption when work with kids with autism
No such thing as a naughty child
I don’t get what you mean by this . There’s lots of Autistic people don’t need 24/7 care . Your now thinking that everyone who is autistic is on the severe end of the spectrum. There is a spectrum for the reason as everyone’s needs vary
But that’s off topic to the post was jusy wondering
Actually the National Autistic Society did a survey and majority of Autistic people preferred condition first language as putting the person first and saying with autism made is sound like it was something they could recover from
Well that’s a completely different thing all together 😅
That works the other way for your view You wouldn’t call them tall John either. Because why it’s apart of them. Not then lol