If you need urgent support, call 999 or go to your nearest A&E. To contact our Crisis Messenger (open 24/7) text THEMIX to 85258.
Read the community guidelines before posting ✨
Right Wing Italians propose castrating rapists
Former Member
Posts: 1,876,323 The Mix Honorary Guru
.
0
Comments
It's about power in my opinion, the power the rapist has over his victim. Anyway, it's a bit of a stupid idea to castrate offenders for several reasons: a) people can be punished and repent etc. and go on to become productive members of society b) it is mutilation, kind of, which is barbaric to be honest c) it's not justice, it's revenge - there is a difference.
firstly its a chemical castration not a physical one, makes them unable to get an erection and orgasm basically
despite the fact this has huge risks, and the fact people should be allowed to be rehabiliated means im a bit
for rapists especially they get off on the power, not much else
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4170963.stm
There's no need for rapes, as there is allways masturbation or in the case of sexual contact - Prostitution for those that cant pull for one reason or another.
At the mo, predatory paedo's are just incarcerated on wings within the penal system with like minded people (Rule 43) where they just swop information, stories etc etc which doesn't help rehabilitate them back into society. Not sure on Home Office stats, but the last time i heard (5 or so years ago) the figures of sucessfull rehabilitation were very, very small.
Surley, after two convictions for serious sex crimes committed against the community (DNA proved) then, chemical castration should be as a matter of fact, with perhaps the death penalty, for any further sex crimes committed.
That then, would take away their desire's and their urges's would it not?
Rape has very little to do with sex or sexual gratification, it's an act of violence.
Prostitutes can be raped too.
I think in this case it would still count as mutilation. I know that many sex offenders may never be rehabilitated but I don't believe any society should use this sort of treatment as punishment. If a child was always violent and would be violent for the rest of their life, you would still say that they should be dealt with in a humane manner (i.e. juvenile detention) rather than just getting a beating from their parents.
Castrate their heads and it's something I could support.
IT won't.
The scum would just use a bottle or other implement instead. The basis of rape is power not sexual gratification.
Executing the cunts would solve the problem though.
then that just serves more to my point that we should focus on the mental issues of rapists more than anything else, i know they're the lowest of the low, but we as humans, should have the mental capacity to re-habilitate ourselves, and for the victims, forgive to a degree, thats providing the accuser is totally repentant and has re-habilitated himself, and that all goes back to sorting out their mental issues...
you must have very strong feelings about the issue then and i don't blame you, though being a bit pragmatic, i don't think cutting their dicks off is the best way to solve the problem
If they have a problem in the head that makes them rape people, then remove the head. No more problems, no more rapist. Perfect.
I would suggest chopping their dicks off if I thought it would do any god, but it wouldn't. Rapists don't have to rape with a penis.
but then we've ALL "raped" someone at some stage in our lives, if what you're saying that rape is about power gratificaiton and not sexual...
also do you think that rapists are incapable of rehabilitation and also incapable of redemption?
Eh? That makes no sense.
I've said before: I have no reason to doubt that some rapists can be safely rehabilitated. What I've said, and I stand by it, is that those vermin do not deserve the chance to be rehabilitated.
They destroy lives, they make people too scared to see themselves in the mirror, they make people kill themselves and suffer awful pain. Why the fuck should some dirty rapist cunt be allowed to ever get out of prison, why the fuck should some filthy rapist ever be allowed to see outside again, why should he be allowed to live when he destroys others' lives.
People very special to me have been raped. If I could get away with it I would kill them. I often joke "Oh, I'd kill him, he deserves ebola", whatever, but on this I am being deadly serious. If I could catch the rapist I am thinking of, and I could get away with it, I would hold a gun to his head and kill him. I would exterminate it like the filth it is. My only regret would be that that is the easy way out for animals like that. Rapists aren't people, and shouldn't be treated as such.
but wouldn't that create a problem with prison crowding? I mean people do live a long time, and eventually it would have to start backlogging right?
Fill the prisons with people who deserve to be there, and get the low-level crims in community or rehab sentences, and there'd be loads of room in prison.
Build more prisons. It would be expensive but as jailing all convicted rapists and paedophiles would almost certainly cut the number of rapes/abuses cost is irrelevant.
...you're kidding of course...right?
I'm not so sure about that. It isn't the cost of building the prisons, it's the cost of paying for the inmates, the guards, the food, the upkeep, etc that gets expensive. And over a long time that could really add up.
I think you're failing to separate emotion from intellect...
Rape is something, often, which is difficult to prove...for obvious reasons.
What about a woman who changes her mind during sex, and the man can't stop until he's finished?
I can't understand the pyschology of a rapist, but you have to take into account aggravating factors, such as past history (abusive family perhaps, molestated as a child etc) etc to gain the full picture and seek to rehabilitate the offender if possible.